Is there a Star Trek versus Star Wars rivalry? It may seem a trite or useless question, but it’s one that people who do actually sometimes consider, and it’s the topic of a DVD you may want to watch.
Whether there is genuinely a rivalry between fans of Star Trek and Star Wars productions or whether these franchises have actually mostly the same fans, as I suspect, you won’t get much of a sense of it from watching Star Wars vs. Star Trek: The Rivalry Continues — available from Amazon.
I’m a fan of Star Trek and will watch anything Paramount offers that is even vaguely related to the Enterprise, Starfleet or Gene Roddenberry’s vision of the future universe. I’ve never seen a Star Wars movie, although I admit to trying to watch one once. For me, there is no rivalry.
A Star Wars vs Star Trek rivalry? Not as far as I’m concerned.
Star Trek wins hands down. Still, I thought an examination of the perceived rivalry would be entertaining.
While the 50-minute documentary includes some interesting interview snippets and a couple of Star Trek bloopers, there is very little real content. A few fans of the two franchises are interviewed, but producers managed to gather no truly insightful or entertaining comments. The production’s key question, “Is there a rivalry between Star Trek and Star Wars fans?”, goes mostly unanswered.
The documentary’s biggest problems are technical, however. Once viewers get past the stuffy announcer, very poor quality video makes the production look even worse than it really it. The images of Star Trek’s original series are blurry bootlegs, while almost all other images are from trailers and press photos.
Sloppy editors even show a nice head shot of DeForest Kelley to introduce an interview sound bite from Star Trek guest actor Michael Forest.
On my DVD player, the documentary starts playing immediately upon inserting the disc. I only learned about the menu and special features later.
Short additional interview material is unintentionally humorous, from a confused Carrie Fisher being interviewed in English and Spanish at the same time to an ultimately useless interview (from the late 1970s but strangely in black and white) with an arrogant William Shatner that fades away mid-sentence.
Amateur footage from the opening of the Star Trek Experience at the Las Vegas Hilton and some Star Wars fan footage that I didn’t bother to watch are also included.
Still, while you may be included to boldly go elsewhere, true devotees of either franchise need to see this DVD so they can write humorous and biting blog and message board posts about it. And it’s at least interesting to watch.
So what about that Star Trek vs Star Wars rivalry? You’ll have to decide that for yourself, but this fun (if not compelling) DVD won’t help you decide.